I run a juicing blog with my wife and one of the questions that we often get from subscribers and visitors is about juicing and weight loss. Since many of us are trying to shift excess weight we are often asked “will juicing for weight loss work for me?”. My reply is always that I don’t recommend it, which surprises people because so many juicing websites advocate it. So then, why am I different in this respect, and why do I think differently.
Extremes
Don’t get me wrong, there are people who have lost weight with a juicing program, this is why the documentary “Fat Sick and Nearly Dead” is so popular these days. My concern is using extreme measures to lose weight, such as radical changes and especially diets that are very low-calorie. The evidence is that extreme and fast weight loss almost always results in putting the weight back on. There are a few exceptions of course, but this is only for those that actually understand that lifestyle changes are the bottom line factor and not taking extremes.
Long-term healthy weight loss maintenance requires adopting a lifestyle that you can maintain for the rest of your life. Yo-yo dieting is ultimately not a healthy approach, and juicing for weight loss can fall into the extreme category for dieting if not done correctly.
Extreme Low-calorie
Drinking 3 to 5 juices a day in place of solid meals will provide around 350 to 1000 calories per day, depending on what juices you make. Fruits are higher in calories than vegetables generally speaking. While starchy vegetables, such as carrots and potatoes are more energy dense than leafy green vegetables. Regardless of what is juiced, the end result is that the amount of calories consumed per day is extremely low and hard to maintain. The better approach, in my opinion, is to eat 3 solid meals a day and use juice as a snack in-between meals. This way you can still drop you daily calorie intake a few 100 calories below your daily needs and lose weight less dramatically and still enjoy all the health benefits that juicing provides. Add some moderate exercise to the picture and you are developing a lifestyle that is healthy and maintainable.
The Sugar Factor
Another issue with juice only diets is the effect on blood sugar levels – it is not good! Fruit juices in particular are very sugary, and since juice contains very little fiber of the original whole fruit, this makes things worse. Fiber slows the rate at which sugar is absorbed from the gut into the blood stream, it is nature’s way of balancing blood sugar. Without the fiber the sugar in fruit juice creates a rapid rise in blood sugar levels. This leads to the inevitable drop in sugar levels, known as the crash. This leads to hunger pangs, concentration lapses and irritability – not a hormonal or psychological situation that you want to be in when trying to shed weight!
Vegetable juice on the other hand contains much less sugar, especially juice made with green vegetables. Green juice is low in sugar and calories and so loaded with vitamins, minerals and antioxidants that they put multi-nutrient supplements to shame. Used as snack between meals, vegetable juice is the perfect addition to a healthy weight loss plan.
The Verdict
“Juicing is an excellent addition to a healthy weight loss plan, providing many nutrients that bring health and wellness to body and mind and help boost metabolism. However, juicing is not the weight loss plan in itself”. I created that statement to really sum-up my view about juicing for weight loss. As a website owner who has promoted juicing for many years, I am a true believer in the health-power of fresh juice; but in terms of juicing and weight loss I don’t think a “juice only” diet is necessarily the best way to go.
Author: Darren Haynes runs JuicerRecipesNow.com with his wife veronica. They blog extensively about juicing, providing free recipes and information about the health benefits of juicing. They also help clear up a lot of misinformation on this topic.
